Signs of Fermentation - Sauerkraut Fermentation Guide

Learn to recognize the signs that tell you your sauerkraut is fermenting properly.

The Fermentation Timeline

Day 0-2: Getting Started

What's happening: Salt is inhibiting bad bacteria, good bacteria are waking up

What you'll see:

Little to no activity
Cabbage still bright in colour
Brine clear
Smells like fresh cabbage and salt

What to do:

Leave it alone!
Don't open the jar
Check that cabbage is submerged

Normal: This quiet period is expected

Day 3-7: Active Fermentation Begins

What's happening: Lactobacillus bacteria are multiplying rapidly, producing CO2 and lactic acid

What you'll see:

✅ Bubbles forming and rising
✅ Cloudy brine (bacteria growth)
✅ Slight fizzing sound when opened
✅ Brine may overflow slightly
✅ Colour begins dulling
✅ Smell becoming tangy/sour

What to do:

Monitor from outside the jar
Burp if using tight lid (once daily)
Place on plate to catch overflow
Still avoid opening frequently

Normal: Most active period, lots of bubbling

Week 2-3: Steady Fermentation

What's happening: Acid levels building, flavour developing, fermentation slowing

What you'll see:

✅ Fewer bubbles but still present
✅ Very cloudy brine
✅ Cabbage turning yellowish
✅ Tangy smell when opened
✅ Sour taste developing

What to do:

Start tasting (after day 7)
Check every 3-4 days
Monitor flavour development
Look for your preferred sourness

Normal: Less dramatic than week 1 but still working

Week 3-6: Final Maturation

What's happening: Final flavour development, fermentation nearly complete

What you'll see:

✅ Minimal bubbling or none
✅ Settled, cloudy brine
✅ Dull yellow-green colour
✅ Strong tangy aroma
✅ Full sour flavour

What to do:

Taste regularly
Move to fridge when flavour is right
Check cabbage is still submerged

Normal: Quiet but still improving in flavour

Key Signs of Healthy Fermentation

Visual Signs

Bubbles

What: Small CO2 bubbles rising through brine

Where:

Rising from bottom
Trapped in cabbage layers
On surface of brine
Inside cabbage pieces

When: Most visible days 3-7

Important:

NOT seeing bubbles doesn't mean it's not fermenting!
Slow/cold fermentation = fewer visible bubbles
Thick cabbage = bubbles trapped inside
Some batches are just less bubbly

Cloudy Brine

What: Brine turns from clear to milky/cloudy

Why: Billions of beneficial bacteria in suspension

When: Starts day 2-4, peaks week 1-2

Important: This is GOOD - means fermentation is active

Colour Change

From: Bright green/white

To: Dull yellow-green/beige

When: Gradual over 2-4 weeks

Why: Chemical changes from fermentation

Important: Natural and expected

White Film on Surface

What: Thin white layer on brine surface

Is it mold?: Probably not - likely kahm yeast

What to do:

Skim it off
Ensure cabbage stays submerged
Usually harmless but can affect flavour
More common in warm fermentation

Smell Signs

Days 1-3: Fresh Cabbage

Clean, vegetable smell
Slightly salty
No fermentation smell yet
Normal: Fermentation hasn't started significantly

Days 4-7: Beginning Fermentation

Slight tanginess
"Vegetal" smell
Can be slightly funky (not rotten)
Normal: Bacteria waking up

Week 2+: Full Fermentation

Pleasantly tangy/sour
Similar to good pickles
"Fermented" smell
Not sweet, not rotten
Normal: This is what you want!

BAD Smells

❌ Rotten eggs (sulfur)
❌ Putrid/decay smell
❌ Ammonia smell
❌ Extremely foul
Not normal: Likely contamination, discard

Taste Signs

Week 1: Still Salty

Predominantly salty
Barely sour
Raw cabbage taste
Normal: Too early

Week 2-3: Getting Sour

Noticeably tangy
Less salty tasting
Developing complexity
Still might be too mild
Normal: On track

Week 3-6: Properly Fermented

Pleasantly sour
Complex, tangy flavour
Salt balanced with acid
No raw cabbage taste
Perfect: Ready or nearly ready!

Texture Signs

Good Texture

✅ Still crunchy (but less than fresh)
✅ Slight give when pressed
✅ Tender but not mushy
✅ Clean bite/snap

Problem Texture

❌ Slimy or slippery
❌ Extremely soft/mushy
❌ Disintegrating
May indicate: Too warm, too long, or problem

Sound Signs

When Opening Jar

Slight "psst": Good - CO2 release
Loud "POP": Very active - normal in first week
No sound: Normal after week 2-3
Bubbling/fizzing: Good - active fermentation

Temperature-Specific Signs

Cool Fermentation (15-18°C)

Expect:

Fewer visible bubbles
Slower colour change
Gradual flavour development
Very crunchy texture maintained
Takes 4-6 weeks

Don't worry about:

Lack of dramatic bubbling
Slow progress
Still salty after 2 weeks

Warm Fermentation (24-27°C)

Expect:

Lots of bubbles
Rapid colour change
Quick flavour development
Softer texture
Ready in 1-2 weeks

Watch for:

Becoming too soft
Moving to fridge sooner

Burping and Pressure Signs

Need to Burp If:

Using tight-fitting lid
Days 2-7 most critical
Lid bulging upward
Difficulty opening lid

How to Burp:

Loosen lid slightly ("crack" it)
Let gas escape (may hear psst)
Re-tighten lid
Takes 5 seconds

Don't Need to Burp If:

Using airlock system
Lid is loosely fitted
Using water bag weight with no lid

What's Normal vs. What's a Problem

Normal and Good ✅

Sign	Why	Action
Bubbles	CO2 from fermentation	None - perfect!
Cloudy brine	Beneficial bacteria	None - excellent!
Colour dulling	Chemical changes	None - expected!
Tangy smell	Lactic acid	None - it's working!
White film (thin)	Kahm yeast	Skim off, continue
Brine overflow	Active fermentation	Clean up, reduce fill level next time
Slower than expected	Cool temp	Be patient, it's fine

Needs Attention ⚠️

Sign	Possible Cause	Action
Cabbage above brine	Weight shifted	Push down, add brine if needed
Thick white film	Kahm yeast overgrowth	Skim, ensure submerged
Very soft texture	Too warm or too long	Move to fridge
Slightly off smell	Normal fermentation funk	Give it time, smell improves
No activity after 7 days	Too cold or wrong salt	Move warmer or wait longer

Problem - Discard ❌

Sign	Cause	Action
Mold (fuzzy, coloured)	Contamination	Discard batch
Putrid smell	Bad bacteria	Discard batch
Pink/slimy texture	Contamination	Discard batch
Black or green discolouration	Mold growth	Discard batch

The "No Bubbles" Question

Your sauerkraut can be fermenting perfectly even without visible bubbles!

Why no bubbles?:

Cool temperature (15-18°C) - CO2 production slower
Thick cabbage - Bubbles trapped inside pieces
Tight packing - Bubbles can't rise easily
Low sugar cabbage - Less CO2 produced
Already past peak - Week 2+ has fewer bubbles

How to know it's still working:

✅ Taste is getting more sour
✅ Smell is tangy
✅ Brine is cloudy
✅ Colour is dulling

If in doubt: Taste it! Your tongue is the best tool.

Using Your Senses

Sight

Colour changes
Brine cloudiness
Bubble activity
Any mold or film

Smell

Tangy = good
Sour = good
Rotten = bad
Sweet = not ready

Taste

Increasingly sour = working
Still salty = needs more time
Complex flavour = getting close
Perfect to you = done!

Touch

Texture in mouth
Crunch level
Not slimy

Hearing

Gas release when opening
Bubbling sounds
"Fizzy" sounds

Checklist: Is My Fermentation Working?

Go through this checklist if you're unsure:

□ Cabbage is submerged in brine

□ Brine is cloudy or getting cloudy

□ Colour has dulled from bright green

□ Smell is tangy/sour (not rotten)

□ Taste is getting more sour over time

□ No visible mold (fuzzy spots)

□ Temperature is 15-24°C

□ It's been at least 7 days

If you checked most of these: Your fermentation is working! Be patient.

If you checked only 1-2: See Troubleshooting

When Is It Done?

The honest answer: When it tastes good to you!

Guidelines:

Minimum: 7 days (for safety - acid development)
Typical: 2-4 weeks (balanced flavour)
Extended: 4-6 weeks (complex, mellow flavour)
Maximum: 2-3 months (very sour, soft texture)

How to decide:

After 2 weeks, taste it
Too salty/not sour enough? Wait 1 more week
Taste again
When it tastes good to YOU, it's done!
Move to fridge

Remember: Flavour continues developing slowly in fridge

Next Steps

Having issues? Check Common Problems & Solutions
Learn about Safety & Quality
Ready to store? See Storage & Preservation

← Back to Index

Next: Troubleshooting →