Cast Iron Skillet Buying Guide

What Is a Cast Iron Skillet?

A cast iron skillet is a heavy-duty frying pan made from a single piece of iron that excels at heat retention and even cooking. When properly seasoned, it develops a natural non-stick surface that improves with age. It's one of the few kitchen tools that can last multiple generations.

Key Factors to Consider

1. Size - Getting It Right

10-12 inch (25-30cm) - RECOMMENDED FOR MOST

• Best for: 90% of home cooking
• Capacity: 2-4 servings
• Uses: Searing steaks, pan pizzas, cornbread, eggs, roasted chicken
• Weight: Manageable for most people (~2-3kg)
• Fits: Standard stovetops and ovens

8-9 inch (20-23cm) - Starter/Secondary

• Best for: Singles, small portions, side dishes
• Lighter: Easier to handle
• Downside: Too small for family cooking

14+ inch (35+cm) - Specialist

• Best for: Large families, entertaining
• Downside: Very heavy, harder to store, needs large stovetop

Verdict: Start with 10-12 inch. You can always add smaller/larger later.

2. Weight & Thickness

Traditional Cast Iron (Lodge, etc.)

• Weight: Heavy! 10" skillet ~2.5kg, 12" ~3.5kg
• Thickness: ~3-5mm
• Pros: Excellent heat retention, even cooking, affordable
• Cons: Heavy to lift and maneuver
• Who it's for: Most people, traditional approach

Lighter Wrought Iron (Solidteknics AUS-ION)

• Weight: 20-30% lighter than cast iron
• Thickness: 3mm
• Pros: Easier to handle, heats faster, still excellent retention
• Cons: More expensive, slightly less heat mass
• Who it's for: Those who want easier handling

Key Insight: "Heavy = quality" is partly a myth. High-quality skillets CAN be lighter while still performing excellently. However, heavier skillets have more thermal mass (stay hot longer). Optimal thickness: 3-5mm bottom. Too thin (<3mm) = hot spots. Too thick (>6mm) = unnecessary weight.

3. Surface Texture & Seasoning

Pre-Seasoned vs Unseasoned

• Pre-seasoned (Lodge): Ready to use, but initial seasoning is basic
• Unseasoned: Requires initial seasoning (multiple coats)
• Verdict: Pre-seasoned is more convenient, but you'll build more seasoning over time anyway

Surface Finish Rough/Pebbly Surface (Lodge)

• Casting texture visible
• More prone to sticking initially
• Smooths out over years of use
• Workaround: Some people sand smooth (labor intensive)

Smooth/Polished Surface (Vintage, Solidteknics, premium brands)

• Better non-stick from day one
• Food releases easier
• More expensive
• Closer to true non-stick with proper seasoning

Does it matter?: Yes and no. Rough lodge pans work great once properly seasoned (6+ months use). Smooth pans are better immediately.

4. Construction Features

Handle

• Should be long enough for good leverage
• Helper handle on opposite side (12" and larger)
• Solid one-piece construction (no rivets to fail)

Pour Spouts

• Dual spouts for left/right hand pouring
• Essential for draining fat, pouring off liquid

Flat Bottom

• Check for wobble on flat surface
• Warped skillets = hot spots

5. Enameled vs Traditional

Traditional Bare Cast Iron (RECOMMENDED)

• Requires seasoning and maintenance
• Develops natural non-stick over time
• Can use metal utensils
• Can withstand very high heat
• Needs to be dried properly (rusts if left wet)
• Best for: Searing, high-heat cooking, building

heirloom piece

Enameled Cast Iron (Le Creuset, Staub)

• No seasoning needed
• Can't rust
• Pretty colors
• Cons: Can chip, can't go as hot, 3-5x more expensive
• Best for: Braising, Dutch ovens, display
• Verdict for skillets: Traditional bare iron is better for frying/searing

Top Recommended Brands

Budget Champion: Lodge ($20-75 AUD)

• Country: USA (made since 1896)
• Price: 10" ~$20-30, 12" ~$40-50
• Surface: Rough/pebbly
• Seasoning: Pre-seasoned with vegetable oil
• Why it's great:
• Incredible value - cheapest quality cast iron
• Proven durability (millions sold)
• Widely available
• Performs as well as pans 10x the price (once seasoned)
• Lifetime of use for <$50
• Downsides:
• Rough surface (takes time to smooth)
• Heavier than wrought iron alternatives
• Where to buy: Amazon AU, Kitchen Warehouse
• Verdict: Best bang for buck. Hard to justify paying more.

Premium Australian: Solidteknics AUS-ION ($180-220 AUD)

• Country: Made in Sydney, Australia
• Price: 26cm (10") ~$220, 30cm (12") ~$250
• Material: Single-sheet Australian wrought iron (not cast)
• Seasoning: Natural pre-seasoning
• Why it's great:
• 20-30% lighter than Lodge (easier handling)
• Smooth surface from day one
• Australian made (support local)
• Multi-century warranty (yes, really!)
• One-piece construction (no welds, no failures)
• Heats faster than cast iron
• Oven/grill/campfire safe
• Downsides:
• Expensive (10x Lodge price)
• Marginally less heat retention than thick cast iron
• Harder to find in stores
• Where to buy: Solidteknics.com, Myer, Kitchen Warehouse
• Verdict: Premium option if you want Australian-made and easier handling

Budget Alternative: Victoria (<$30 AUD)

• Colombian brand
• Similar to Lodge
• Sometimes cheaper
• Quality is good but less proven history

Artisan/Vintage Reproduction: Butter Pat, Finex ($150-250)

• Smooth surface
• Beautiful design
• American-made craftsmanship
• Verdict: Hard to justify unless you're a collector

What Should You Pay?

Price Range	What You Get	Value Proposition
-------------	--------------	-------------------
$20-50	Lodge, Victoria	BEST VALUE - performs same as $200+ pans
$50-100	Larger Lodge sizes, import brands	Same performance, paying for size
$100-150	Premium imports	Diminishing returns
$180-250	Solidteknics, Finex, artisan	Smooth finish, lighter weight, aesthetics, local manufacturing
$250+	Collectors, vintage	You're paying for art/history, not performance

Expert Consensus: Lodge at $25-50 performs just as well as $200 pans for actual cooking. The extra cost buys smoother surface, lighter weight, and aesthetics.

Buying Options in Australia

Budget Option: Lodge

Amazon Australia

• Lodge 26cm (10.25"): $73 (often on sale ~$20-30 USD shipped)
• Lodge 30cm (12"): ~$45-55
• Free shipping with Prime
• Genuine Lodge product

Kitchen Warehouse

• Lodge range
• Free shipping >$100
• Can bundle with other items

Catch/eBay

• Watch for sales
• Sometimes under $30

Premium Option: Solidteknics

Solidteknics Direct

• Website: solidteknics.com
• AUS-ION 26cm: $219.95
• AUS-ION 30cm: $249.95
• Direct from manufacturer
• Multi-century warranty

Myer

• In-store and online
• Can use Myer gift cards/discounts
• Sometimes on sale

Kitchen Warehouse

• Sometimes stocked
• Free shipping available

Making the Decision

Choose Lodge if:

• Budget conscious ($25-50 vs $220)
• Want proven, reliable workhorse
• Don't mind heavier weight
• Willing to build seasoning over time
• This is the smart choice for 90% of people

Choose Solidteknics if:

• Weight is a concern (arthritis, wrist issues, frequent pan movement)
• Want best-in-class from day one
• Value Australian manufacturing
• Want smoother surface immediately
• Budget allows for premium tool
• Appreciate lifetime (multi-century!) warranty

Skip if:

• You already have good non-stick pans (cast iron isn't essential)
• You cook mostly delicate foods (fish, eggs) - non-stick is easier
• Storage space is very limited (they're bulky)
• You have wrist/shoulder issues and can't lift heavy pans

Seasoning & Maintenance Basics

Initial Seasoning (If Unseasoned or Building on Pre-Seasoning)

1. Wash with soap and water, dry completely

2. Preheat oven to 230°C (450°F)

3. Apply thin coat of oil (flaxseed, grapeseed, or vegetable)

4. Wipe off excess until it looks dry

5. Bake upside-down for 1 hour

6. Let cool in oven

7. Repeat 3-6 times for best results

Daily Maintenance

• After cooking: Wipe out while warm, rinse with hot water
• If stuck food: Use coarse salt as scrub, rinse
• Dry thoroughly: Towel dry + 1 min on stove to evaporate all moisture
• Light oil coat: Rub thin layer of oil on surface
• Storage: Store dry, can stack with paper towel between

Dos

• ✓ Use metal utensils (won't hurt seasoning)
• ✓ Preheat gradually for even heating
• ✓ Cook acidic foods occasionally (won't hurt modern seasoning)
• ✓ Use on stovetop, oven, grill, campfire
• ✓ Dry immediately after washing
• ✓ Re-season if food starts sticking

Don'ts

• ✗ Never put in dishwasher
• ✗ Don't leave soaking in water (rusts!)
• ✗ Don't store wet
• ✗ Don't use harsh detergents (though modern soap is fine)
• ✗ Don't heat empty on high (can crack/warp)

If It Rusts

Not a disaster! Scrub off rust with steel wool, re-season. Good as new.

The Bottom Line

Best Value: Lodge 26cm (10") for $25-75 AUD

• Performs identically to $200+ pans
• Will last 100+ years
• Same one used in top restaurants
• Available on Amazon AU or Kitchen Warehouse

Splurge Worth It?: Solidteknics if weight/handling is important

• Meaningfully lighter (20-30%)
• Smoother surface from day one
• Australian-made quality
• But Lodge will cook just as well for 1/10th the price

Quick Recommendation

For your mum's kitchen: Option 1 (Budget): Lodge 26cm from Amazon AU (~$73, watch for sales)

• Unbeatable value
• Classic American cast iron
• Will last her lifetime and then some

Option 2 (Premium): Solidteknics AUS-ION 26cm ($220)

• If lighter weight matters (easier to handle)
• Supports Australian manufacturing
• Smooth surface, ready to go
• Worth it if budget allows and handling is a concern

Either choice: She'll have a skillet that improves with age and never wears out. Cast iron is one of the few tools that gets better over time.

---

Last updated: October 2025